The reader’s shortlist

Worth a second thought.

Essays ranked by captured source likes. Essays without a saved count are listed last.

Most liked essays

2,008 essays

More thoughts on assertions

Scott analyzes when assertions should be trusted, showing that their evidentiary value depends on whether you already know the belief's distribution, the asserter's credentials, and how you encountered them, while claims of having 'evidence' mostly serve as signals of rationality rather than factual proof.

Cleaning up the "Worst Argument" essay

Scott Alexander introduces 'Guilt by Association' as a fallacy where people judge things negatively based on category membership rather than actual shared features, using examples like calling MLK a 'criminal' or abortion 'murder' to illustrate when this reasoning fails.

11 min read 1,683 words